Congratulations, You Beat the Player and Won Yourself a Player
Meeting a man who likes to play games can be strangely exciting at first, mostly because you do not realize you have entered a competition.
Sir is charming, attentive and just elusive enough to keep things interesting. One minute he is very much there, the next he has wandered off into the mist, only to pop up later with a casual little message suggesting that absolutely nothing unusual has happened.

You notice the pattern, naturally, and eventually decide that if Sir would like to play, fine.
You can play too.
Not because you particularly enjoy games. You simply refuse to be the woman wondering why Sir has gone quiet while he is somewhere enjoying the mystery of himself. So if he takes hours to reply, perhaps you are not in any hurry either. If he becomes unavailable, marvelous, you have plans. And should another woman float casually into conversation, your own life suddenly becomes so interesting it practically requires reservations in advance.
Before long, what began as dating starts to look suspiciously like a poker game, complete with stakes, bluffing and two people pretending not to care too much.
Nobody Is Showing Their Hand
Once you realize Sir enjoys a little uncertainty, you become wonderfully good at providing it.
Messages no longer get the reply you would have sent without thinking; they get something a little breezier, while perfectly free evenings become pleasantly vague and your availability starts looking far more mysterious than it really is. Before long, you have stopped wondering aloud when you might see him and developed the serene air of a woman whose calendar is apparently controlled by several glamorous people Sir has never met.
And goodness, it works.
The less certain Sir becomes of you, the more closely he starts watching the table, and the man who once seemed perfectly relaxed about disappearing begins noticing every time you do the same. Before long, he is asking more questions, replying faster and showing a sudden interest in your plans, until Sir—who once treated next weekend as a distant land nobody could possibly predict—would now very much like to know exactly what you are doing.
Well, at this point, the whole thing is becoming tremendously satisfying.
You have not chased him or demanded anything. You have simply kept your cards close, and Sir has responded by leaning farther and farther across the table.
Naturally, it is becoming difficult not to feel rather pleased with yourself. Perhaps you have cracked the code. Perhaps Sir was never impossible after all. Or perhaps he simply needed a woman with a better poker face.
Winning feels marvelous right up until you look closely at what you won
Alexandra
Sir Has Suddenly Become Very Interested in Winning
Naturally, you keep going, because by now the game is becoming rather enjoyable. Sir pulls back and you let him, he becomes mysterious and you become positively enchanting, until two people who supposedly like each other are spending an impressive amount of energy making sure neither looks too interested.
Very romantic.
Except the stakes are quietly getting higher. A little jealousy wanders in and makes itself comfortable, and Sir, who once seemed perfectly happy to leave your attention unattended, suddenly becomes rather particular about where it goes. The more difficult you are to pin down, the more closely he watches the table, until somewhere along the way it dawns on you that you are no longer simply keeping up with the game.
You are winning.
And goodness, that is the delicious little problem with outplaying a player: sometimes it works beautifully. Sir becomes more fascinated, the chase gets more interesting, and the woman he cannot quite figure out begins to look very much like the woman he wants.
Naturally, this feels fabulous. The man who once had you wondering what he was thinking is now wondering what you are thinking, which is exactly the sort of reversal a woman could enjoy over a very nice glass of something while trying not to look too pleased with herself.
The only tiny complication is that, sooner or later, somebody has to look across the table and remember what the prize actually is.
The Chips Come Sliding Across the Table
And eventually, Sir may give you exactly what you wanted.
He chooses you.
The messages become regular. The plans become real. The mysterious man who once floated in and out of your life may now want exclusivity. The cards come down, the chips slide across the table and somewhere in the distance one can almost hear the triumphant little music.
You did it.
You beat the player at his own game.
Then you look across the table and realize that Sir is still Sir.
He is still the man who seemed most interested when affection became uncertain, who moved closer when you stepped away and who suddenly paid very close attention the moment he thought yours might be wandering elsewhere.
And meanwhile, you have become remarkably good at hiding the very things you once hoped he would notice—that you like him, that you want to see him and that, heaven forbid, you are sometimes actually free on Saturday.
So now we have two people who like each other very much, sitting across from one another and trying not to look too delighted about it because somebody might lose the upper hand.
Marvelous.
And that is when the whole arrangement begins to look rather absurd, because you sat down hoping Sir would eventually stop playing games and somehow ended up learning his game, becoming excellent at it and beating him beautifully.
The chips came sliding your way, so yes—congratulations. You won!
Unfortunately, Sir himself—your charming little player—was the prize.

Continue reading
A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between
A little more support
If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.
Explore online counseling →I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.
From Alexandra’s bookshelf
What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.
Explore the book →