You Keep Making It Very Easy for Him Not to Choose You

Unrequited love has one particularly sneaky little habit: it can keep you extremely busy.

You are thinking about him, wondering about him, arranging things, keeping conversations alive, finding reasons to see him, interpreting his moods and generously making room for the possibility that he may simply need a little more time.

Meanwhile, Sir may be doing remarkably little.

And this is where things get interesting.

Because he may very well like you. He may enjoy your company, feel attracted to you, miss you now and then and say just enough encouraging things to keep hope sitting comfortably at the table.

But what happens if you stop giving the whole thing quite so much help?

Goodness.

That can be an unexpectedly quiet afternoon.

You May Be Doing Both Sides of the Romance

A man tells you he is unsure, and somehow you respond by becoming certain enough for both of you.

He does not suggest seeing you, so somehow you end up suggesting it. The conversation begins fading, and there you are giving it another little push. Sir hesitates, and before long you are making everything beautifully easy in case the poor man is frightened by the alarming prospect of deciding what he wants.

At some point, you are no longer simply in the relationship, you appear to be running both sides of it. The invitations, the patience, the understanding, the affection and enough benefit of the doubt to furnish a small hotel all seem to be coming from your side.

Sir, meanwhile, gets to remain undecided in extremely comfortable conditions.

And really, why wouldn’t he?

Nothing terribly inconvenient happens when he does not choose. You are still there, the conversation carries on, the affection keeps arriving, and Sir gets all the lovely parts of having you in his life without becoming particularly clear about what he intends to do with you.

It is a very comfortable little setup.

Especially for Sir.

Sir’s Confusion Is Living Rather Well

This can be surprisingly hard to notice when you are busy being understanding.

You think all that patience is giving the relationship a chance, and sometimes it is. But sometimes all that kindness simply gives Sir a very pleasant place to remain undecided.

He says he does not know what he wants, and somehow you make sure he loses absolutely nothing while he thinks about it. No need to hurry, Sir. Everything is still here exactly as you like it.

Would Sir like a snack while deciding whether he loves you?

The sneaky part is that all your devotion can protect him from the very thing you desperately want to know: does he want you badly enough to come toward you himself?

Hard to tell, Madam, when you keep meeting him halfway, three-quarters of the way and, on ambitious days, practically at his front door.

If he never has to choose, Sir may become terribly fond of not choosing

Alexandra

And because you are still warm, available and endlessly understanding, Sir may think the whole arrangement is going rather nicely, which is interesting considering you are quietly miserable on the other side of it.

Quite a difference in reviews.

Attraction Is Not the Same Thing as Choosing You

A man can feel quite a lot for you and still somehow do absolutely nothing useful with those feelings.

He can be attracted to you, enjoy kissing you, love talking to you, think you are wonderful and still leave the whole thing sitting exactly where he found it. Naturally, we tend to become rather excited by the first half of that sentence—he feels something! Excellent. The second half is usually where things become less festive

Unfortunately, feelings can be lazy little creatures. They may sit around for months looking terribly meaningful without ever going anywhere. But eventually, one does begin to wonder whether Sir plans to take them anywhere.

And this is where one-sided love becomes almost comic: you keep adding more love in the hope that eventually the scales will tip, while Sir remains on his side looking thoughtful, as though another thoughtful expression might finally move things along. It probably will not. Giving someone more of your love does not automatically produce more of theirs; sometimes it simply means they get to enjoy an impressive amount of yours.

Marvelous for them.

Then You Notice Who Has Been Keeping This Thing Going

At some point, everything Sir has said starts becoming a little less interesting than the pattern sitting right in front of you. You are the one reaching out, finding reasons to see each other, giving fading conversations another nudge and smoothing over those awkward little moments when his uncertainty begins peeking through. Sir may have plenty of feelings, but somehow you seem to be the one making sure those feelings continue to have somewhere to go.

And then, perhaps because you are tired of doing quite so much, you try something almost ridiculously simple: you leave the whole thing alone for a minute.

Not as a trick, and certainly not as one of those romantic performances where you wait four hours to answer a text while spending three hours and fifty-nine minutes staring at the phone. You simply stop doing Sir’s half as well as your own and see what happens when the relationship has to move without you quietly pushing it from behind.

Goodness, things can become clear rather quickly.

Maybe Sir comes toward you. Maybe he suddenly discovers initiative has been available to him all along. Or perhaps everything simply stays exactly where you left it, which is not especially romantic but is wonderfully informative.

Because sometimes the love story did not keep going because two people were moving toward each other. It kept going because you were very good at keeping it alive.

Sir was never exactly refusing to join in.

You simply made it wonderfully easy for him not to.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →