In This Cinderella Story, Sir Is the One Who Leaves at Midnight
Once upon a very modern time, you fall for a married man. Which means, rather inconveniently, that you are the other woman.
Stated plainly, this sounds considerably less romantic than it can feel while you are living it, because Sir may be charming, attentive and terribly good at making an ordinary evening seem as though somebody has quietly brought in an orchestra. He listens, remembers the little story you told him weeks ago and looks at you as though the rest of the room has politely agreed to disappear.

When the two of you are together, it can be surprisingly easy to forget that somewhere beyond all this lovely lighting is a wife and an entirely separate life.
So yes, it is a fairy tale.
Just not the usual version.
In this Cinderella story, Sir is the one who has to leave at midnight.
The Magic Is Lovely While It Lasts
Midnight is not always midnight exactly, naturally. Sometimes it is dinner ending sooner than you would like. Sometimes it is the weekend he cannot give you. Sometimes it arrives disguised as Christmas, a birthday or a family gathering that already has a very clear guest list.
Still, while the music is playing, the clock is remarkably easy to ignore.
And goodness, the evening can be lovely. Sir may tell you things he says nobody else knows, notice when something is bothering you before you say a word and talk about missing you with enough feeling to make the complicated parts seem temporarily very far away.
Perhaps Sir talks about the future too, and naturally it sounds lovely. One day things will be different, life will be simpler and the two of you will no longer have to work around quite so much. One day is wonderfully romantic that way; it asks for neither reservations nor an actual date.
So you enjoy the music, the conversation and those lovely hours when everything feels easy enough to forget how complicated it really is. Then Sir glances at the time, and suddenly the evening changes shape.
He has to go.
Back to his wife. Back to the life that continues when your evening with him is over.
And then, of course, another lovely evening comes along. The music starts again, Sir looks at you in that way that makes everything else feel very far away, and for a few delicious hours it is terribly easy to believe that surely something this romantic must be leading somewhere.
A married man can make forever sound very convincing in surprisingly small doses
Alexandra
Surely One Evening Midnight Will Forget
After enough of these magical evenings, a perfectly understandable thought begins to appear.
Perhaps one evening the clock simply will not matter.
Perhaps circumstances will finally change. Perhaps Sir will look at you, look at the time and decide that the rules which governed every previous evening no longer apply.
It is a beautiful possibility.
The clock, however, has shown extraordinary dedication to its work.
The romance may deepen, the promises may grow warmer and the future may be discussed in increasingly lovely detail, yet midnight continues arriving exactly where it always has.
Holidays are particularly efficient at pointing this out. Christmas morning, it turns out, has rather firm ideas about where married men belong.
Gradually, you become very good at enjoying the music without entirely forgetting the time, because that is the tricky part of being the other woman: the magic can be real enough to make you doubt the limits around it.
The Pumpkin Was Always Part of the Story
Eventually, though, the pattern becomes difficult to miss. Another beautiful evening arrives, Sir returns, everything feels possible again—and eventually so does midnight.
Which is when the fairy tale begins to look slightly different, because the clock is no longer an unfortunate interruption to the relationship.
The clock is part of the relationship.
Sir may genuinely love you. He may mean every tender thing he says and sincerely wish that life were easier. But the romance keeps returning to the same shape: wonderful while the spell is working, complicated the moment the rest of his life comes back into view.
You may have spent all this time waiting for the evening when the carriage would finally remain a carriage.
Sir, however, may have become rather comfortable with the magic exactly as it is.
After all, he has the music, the romance and the beautiful woman waiting for him—and when midnight comes, he still has a wife to go home to.
Which leaves you with the rather inconvenient lesson Cinderella never had to learn.
The problem was never that the carriage kept turning back into a pumpkin.
It was believing that one evening it wouldn’t.
Continue reading
A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between
A little more support
If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.
Explore online counseling →I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.
From Alexandra’s bookshelf
What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.
Explore the book →