The Party Stopped Being Fun, but Somehow You’re Still Here

By the time you start wondering whether you have a good enough reason to leave your relationship, you may already have spent months wanting to go.

But wanting to go feels oddly flimsy. You would prefer something more useful—a spectacular argument, a shocking discovery, at the very least one sentence you can repeat to your girlfriends and watch every one of them put down her wine and say, “Oh, darling. Leave.”

Instead, Sir is merely Sir.

Nothing has exploded. He can still be lovely sometimes. You had a perfectly nice dinner recently, he made you laugh in the car, and for twenty minutes everything felt almost normal, which is extremely inconvenient when you have been quietly wondering whether you can bear another year of this.

So you stay.

Goodness.

This is beginning to sound very much like a party you have wanted to leave for the past hour.

You Were Actually Planning to Leave

Imagine you are at a birthday party that stopped being fun hours ago.

You had a lovely time at first. You talked, laughed, ate something nice. But now you are tired, your social sparkle has packed up for the evening, and you have started looking toward the door with the tenderness normally reserved for old friends.

You could simply go, except the cake is about to come out.

Well. Obviously you cannot leave before the cake.

Then everyone starts singing, plates appear, and somebody insists you take the piece with the raspberry because “you’ll love it.” Suddenly you are eating dessert in a place you were absolutely leaving twenty minutes ago.

Fine. After cake.

Except now a friend you barely spoke to all evening comes over and begins telling you something that clearly has chapters. You cannot disappear halfway through Chapter Two. Then somebody tops up your glass, somebody else says, “You’re not leaving yet, are you?” and somehow another half hour slips away while your coat continues having a perfectly pleasant evening without you.

Madam, you wanted to go home an hour ago. How are you still here holding cake?

The Party Has Improved for Eleven Minutes

An unhappy relationship can do something very similar. It does not have to become wonderful again. It only needs one good evening.

Sir is sweet. You laugh together. He remembers something you told him months ago, and perhaps he reaches for your hand in that familiar way that still does something annoyingly effective to you. For a moment, everything feels easy again—which is, of course, exactly when leaving starts to feel complicated.

Ah. Now what?

Suddenly that one lovely dinner is sitting at the head of the table looking terribly important, while the previous six months are expected to behave themselves.

Maybe things really are changing. One lovely evening can do remarkable things to your confidence in a relationship, and before long you are wondering whether it would be terribly unfair to make any decisions while Sir is being so delightful over pasta.

And the party has just brought out another tray, so naturally you stay.

If you have been looking at the door all evening, perhaps the party has already told you enough

Alexandra

Then come the little worries. What if you regret it? What if this really was just a rough patch? What if you leave three weeks before Sir miraculously becomes the man you have spent two years hoping he might become?

Wouldn’t that be just your luck?

So you give it a little longer, and somewhere in the background someone starts another playlist. You begin to suspect this evening may never actually end.

Perhaps You Can Just Go Home

After a while, the whole thing starts looking a little ridiculous. You have wanted to leave for quite some time, yet every possible moment somehow presents itself as the one moment a decent woman could not possibly choose. Sir is stressed, so leaving now feels heartless. Then the vacation is approaching, and surely you are not going to spoil that. A little later things improve, which is frankly no help at all, because now Sir is being charming over dinner and remembering how you take your coffee.

Wonderful. Just when you had almost made up your mind, the man has decided to be delightful.

And so you do exactly what you did at the party: you linger. Not because you have suddenly begun having a marvelous time again, but because you remain convinced that a cleaner, kinder, more obvious moment to leave must be somewhere ahead.

Of course, this would all be much easier if Sir would simply give you one spectacular reason to go.

Perhaps he could do something so unmistakably awful that all doubt would simply evaporate. Something you could recount to your girlfriends over wine without having to spoil the story halfway through with, “But he really can be lovely.”

That would be helpful.

Instead, Sir continues being complicated. The relationship continues offering just enough good moments to keep the question open, and you continue hoping that one day the answer will arrive wearing a large hat and introduce itself properly.

But you see, the party may never become dreadful enough to send you running for the door.

The cake can still be delicious. The host can still be lovely. You may have adored the beginning of the evening and laughed until your cheeks hurt somewhere in the middle. None of that means you must remain until the last guest is gone and somebody is wandering around collecting abandoned glasses.

At some point, you may simply find yourself in the hallway looking at your coat and realizing that you have spent half the evening waiting for permission to do something you already know you want to do.

You would like to go home now.

No drama. No terrible scene. No cake in flames.

Just your coat, Madam.

And perhaps that is enough.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →