Sorry, We’re Closed: When You’re Finally Done With Him

You would think the moment you finally get rid of a man who has been exhausting your patience for months would arrive with some grandeur.

But usually, it arrives on an ordinary evening when he does one very small thing.

Not even his worst thing.

That is the ridiculous part.

He has already survived disappearing for three days, returning with a story that required unusual levels of generosity, forgetting things you distinctly remember telling him, and several conversations in which you said some version of, “I really cannot keep doing this,” only to discover that, somehow, you were still doing it.

Your tolerance has been running an establishment with extremely generous opening hours.

He knows this place.

He has been coming here for months.

The sign may say CLOSING SOON, but he has learned not to panic. You have said that before. Usually there is still time for another excuse, another apology, another little misunderstanding that somehow needs to be examined from seventeen angles before everyone agrees to continue as before.

He has become very comfortable with your closing announcements.

And then one night, he wanders in five minutes before closing and asks for one more thing.

Something tiny.

And you look at him.

Oh.

We are closed.

Somehow, Closing Time Kept Getting Extended

You did try.

That is what makes the whole thing so funny in retrospect.

You told him what bothered you. You explained it again in slightly different words, in case the first batch had somehow arrived in Portuguese. You listened to his side. You considered whether you were being too sensitive, too impatient, too demanding, insufficiently understanding of whatever unusual forces had prevented a grown man from sending a text message for forty-eight hours.

Then you gave him another chance, possibly followed by the lesser-known cousin of another chance: one final chance. And because language is flexible and love is optimistic, eventually there was one absolutely final chance.

At some point, “final” became more of a decorative adjective.

He noticed.

Of course he noticed.

Not consciously, necessarily. He was not sitting at home rubbing his hands together and calculating how many extensions remained. He had simply seen that closing sign before, and somehow the door always opened again.

You could be furious on Thursday and warm again by Saturday. Something you had firmly declared unacceptable had a funny habit of being accepted anyway.

So when you said, “I’m serious this time,” he heard you.

He just had excellent reason to believe the establishment might reopen.

And Then He Does Something Almost Insultingly Small

This is the part nobody tells you.

After everything you tolerated, you may expect the final straw to be magnificent.

It often is not.

Maybe he cancels dinner for the fourth time. Or he sends “hey” after vanishing all weekend. Or he says the exact same sentence he said during the previous argument, and you suddenly realize you could finish it for him.

And something inside you simply stops negotiating. Nothing explodes; you just stop.

He is still talking, possibly making quite a reasonable case for why this particular incident should not be considered alongside all the others, and meanwhile you are mentally turning the sign around.

CLOSED.

It is almost comical how calm you can become.

Three months earlier, the same behavior might have sent you into a two-hour conversation involving questions, tears, analysis and a friend receiving screenshots at 10:52 p.m.

Now you are looking at the screen thinking, No, thank you.

Sometimes peace begins the moment you finally stop extending the opening hours

Alexandra

The man has not changed in the last six minutes. You have. Or maybe your patience has simply discovered that it has other plans for the evening.

And the slightly ridiculous part is that you already knew all of this. You had simply been keeping the place open while hoping the customer might eventually stop knocking over the glasses.

He Is Often Quite Surprised to Discover You Meant It

Naturally, this is when he becomes very interested in the operating hours.

Wait.

What do you mean you are done?

Can we talk?

Why are you being so final?

This can be especially baffling to a man who has watched you reconsider before. From his perspective, the place was open last week. He still has the loyalty card.

And suddenly he is outside while you are locking the door.

You may still get the urge to explain the closing one more time — properly this time, beautifully, with every reason lined up so neatly that surely he cannot possibly miss the point.

But by now, you have probably explained enough.

The man has had the brochure.

He knows where the bathrooms are.

At some point, closing does not require a seminar. And once you stop trying to make him understand, you may discover that kicking him to the curb feels far less triumphant than you imagined. Mostly, it feels quiet. You make dinner, wash your face and put your phone somewhere you cannot stare at it every seven minutes, which turns out to be a surprisingly respectable celebration.

After a while, you notice you are not even wondering whether he understands anymore.

The place is closed.

He can understand it tomorrow. He can understand it next spring. He can stand outside with a magnificent speech while a small violin trio plays behind him and somebody, for reasons nobody fully understands, begins singing a serenade.

None of that changes the sign.

After months of extended hours, exceptions, second chances and one absolutely final chance that somehow had a sequel, you finally did the most astonishing thing of all.

You flipped the sign to CLOSED — and this time, it stayed that way permanently.

✦

Continue reading

A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →