You Can Like Him Terribly and Still Remember You’re Choosing Too

You can lose an astonishing amount of perspective once you really like a man.

Before him, you had preferences, opinions, standards. You knew perfectly well what made you happy and what made you want to go home early.

Then Sir appears, you fancy him terribly, and suddenly the evening has the faint atmosphere of a game show. And before you know it, you are no longer deciding whether you like him. You are wondering whether he likes you.

Nobody tells you this, mind you. There is no host and no little bell goes off. Yet before long, you are answering questions that were never actually asked.

He likes easygoing women?

Wonderful. You have never been easier going.

He loves women who are independent?

Perfect. You need absolutely nothing, possibly not even a text back.

He says his ex was “too emotional”?

How fortunate that you have recently stopped having feelings.

And so the game begins.

You Would Very Much Like to Make It to the Next Round

The funny thing is that you may not even notice yourself doing it.

You are not pretending to be another woman. Goodness, no. You are just making little changes here and there because you like him and would rather not ruin something that might become lovely.

So you laugh a little longer at the joke. You say you do not mind when, actually, you mind quite a lot. You become remarkably relaxed about something that bothered you perfectly well before he became handsome.

And now almost all your attention is on him.

Did he seem interested?

Was that text warm enough?

Did he look at you differently after dinner?

Your girlfriends are brought in afterward, and between them they can usually find seventeen possible meanings in a man saying, “Had a nice time.”

What gets rather less attention is whether you had a nice time.

Curious, really.

You are so busy hoping to be chosen that your own opinion has quietly slipped out for a drink.

The heart may be smitten, but it is still allowed to have preferences

Alexandra

The Competition Becomes Surprisingly Elaborate

Once you care this much about being picked, you can start finding things about yourself that suddenly seem to need work.

Maybe you should be prettier. Thinner. More mysterious. Less available. More available, but in a way that suggests you simply happened to be standing near your phone for three consecutive hours.

Maybe your hair needs something. Maybe you could be a little easier, a little cooler, a little less bothered by things that do, in fact, bother you.

You can spend forty minutes creating the impression that you required no effort whatsoever, which is one of femininity’s more ambitious little projects.

Meanwhile, somewhere across the room, another woman does not seem to be competing at all.

She is not necessarily prettier than you, younger than you, thinner than you, or mysteriously glowing from within. She has simply remembered something you temporarily misplaced.

She is choosing too.

She can like a man enormously and still notice when she does not like the way he treats her. His excellent jawline does not receive special permission to make her miserable. And if what he wants does not suit her, she does not immediately begin trimming pieces off herself until the relationship fits.

Oddly enough, this woman often looks very lucky in love.

Not because she discovered some secret lipstick. She simply never forgot that her own heart still had a say.

Someone Should Probably Look at the Prize

This is where the whole thing becomes rather funny.

You can spend weeks trying to become the woman a man wants without stopping to ask whether you particularly enjoy the man.

He may be charming but unreliable, gorgeous but exhausting, fascinating for ninety minutes and considerably less fascinating once you have heard the same story twice.

But by then, you are already much too interested in being liked.  This is because Sir has become the prize before anyone has properly inspected the prize.

Eventually, you may look up from all this excellent self-improvement and notice that he is not merely a handsome man with nice shoulders. He has habits, moods, manners, opinions and a surprisingly devoted relationship with his phone.

And suddenly, the question is no longer whether he wants you. It is whether you like who you are when you are with him.

Funny how little attention that question gets while everybody is busy admiring the jawline.

The women who seem lucky in love are not always the prettiest women in the room. They are not necessarily the ones who knew exactly what to say, wore exactly the right thing, or managed to seem wonderfully unbothered while privately wondering why Sir had not texted since lunch.

Quite often, they are simply the women who did not disappear the moment a man they liked walked in.

They liked him, certainly. They may even have liked him terribly.

They just remembered that liking a man does not mean he gets to do all the choosing.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →