Your Relationship Has Been Cancelled Three Times and Somehow There’s Another Season

Some relationships end.

Others end, come back, end again, take a little break, send a text, and return with an entirely new season despite nobody remembering asking for one.

You know this relationship. The breakup was real enough: tears, girlfriends on the phone, his name discussed at generous length over wine. Eventually, you stopped checking your phone every six minutes and discovered the surprising luxury of getting through an evening without wondering what Sir was thinking.

By then, the series really did feel over.

Then your phone lights up.

Hey. Been thinking about you.

Well.

Nobody move.

The show has been renewed.

Previously, on Your Love Life

Sir returns looking wonderfully familiar, which is unfortunate because familiar can look terribly romantic after a few weeks apart.

He still knows exactly how to make you laugh, and you still know the little expression he makes when he is trying not to. The chemistry, which had been given plenty of time to settle down and think about what it had done, immediately runs across the room and throws itself at him.

And because you have missed him, his return feels important. Surely a man does not come all the way back unless something has changed, right?

Well, this is one of those romance’s more imaginative little ideas.

Sir may simply have missed you, and you may simply have missed Sir. Neither of these things has fixed what went wrong, but goodness, they make a lovely opening episode.

So you talk. He says he has been thinking, you say you have too, and both of you seem softer now. Absence has been terribly helpful here; it has quietly edited out most of the scenes involving disappointment and left you with the ones where he looked wonderful across a dinner table.

And just like that, Season Two begins, with both of you looking wonderfully refreshed by the break and the old problems nowhere in sight—at least for the opening episode.

For a while, things really are better. You are affectionate, hopeful, careful with each other, and neither of you is especially eager to spoil this beautiful reunion by mentioning the exact behavior that caused the finale. A little spoiler alert: there will be time for that later.

A man can be terribly hard to forget and still be very easy to regret

Alexandra

The New Season Starts Looking Awfully Familiar

A few episodes into the new season, however, you begin to have the funny little feeling that you have seen this one before. And then, right on cue, Sir does the thing.

Not necessarily a terrible thing. Just the thing. The one you spent half of last season discussing with your girlfriends while they made increasingly serious faces and eventually stopped pretending to be surprised.

You notice it, of course, but this is the new season. Perhaps we should give the writers a chance?

Then you do your thing, he does his, and before long this shiny new season is beginning to look suspiciously like the one you already watched. That is the little magic trick of the on-again, off-again romance: everything comes back feeling fresh, while both of you have quietly packed the same old habits and brought them along for the weekend.

The chemistry, meanwhile, is behaving beautifully. Of course it is. Chemistry has never cared whether either of you learned anything; give it one excellent kiss and it is perfectly happy to erase several weeks of very useful disappointment. Add a romantic dinner, a flattering outfit, Sir looking particularly lovely across the table, and suddenly the reunion begins to feel like a marvelous idea. The reason you broke up is still there, naturally. It has simply been asked to sit quietly for dessert.

So when the next breakup comes, it is painful, yes, but perhaps no longer a complete surprise. Your girlfriends receive the news with the affectionate exhaustion of women who know the cast, remember the earlier seasons, and could probably tell you where this episode is heading before you finish the first glass of wine. By now, even you are beginning to lose track of which goodbye was meant to be the final one.

You tell them that this time it really is over.

They nod very sweetly.

Nobody places a bet.

Surely We Are Not Doing Season Three

Season Two ends much as these seasons tend to end, and after a while Sir’s name loses some of its electricity. You are doing rather well, actually, until two familiar words appear on your phone (again!):

I miss you.

Really?! Somebody please hide the remote.

Of course you miss him too, and this is exactly how Season Three gets its opening scene. Sir remembers the lovely parts, you remember the lovely parts, and chemistry is delighted to help everybody forget the rest. How marvelous.

Going back is not always foolish, of course, because people do change. But coming back is not the same as coming back different, and missing each other can feel terribly romantic without making the old problem disappear.

Distance has also been very generous. Sir has been edited down to his best scenes, and you have received exactly the same flattering treatment.

So before the opening credits begin again, one question will do: what has actually changed?

Because if the answer is nothing, this may not be a great love story finding its way back.

It may simply be a rerun with a much prettier opening scene.

Sir can return for another season, certainly. But somebody might want to check whether the writers changed anything this time around.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →