Three Breakup Truths That Feel Wrong Before They Feel Obvious
A breakup does something rather cheeky to your feelings: it gives each one a microphone.
Sadness arrives first and immediately has opinions. Memory would like everyone to gather around because it has found a lovely weekend from eighteen months ago. Relief is sitting quietly in the corner, slightly embarrassed to be enjoying the peace. Meanwhile, your actual common sense has gone upstairs for a lie-down.
The strange part is how quickly we begin treating all this emotional noise as information.
I feel awful. Maybe I made the wrong decision.
I suddenly remembered how wonderful he was in Vienna. Maybe that means something.
I miss him, but I also slept beautifully last night and nobody annoyed me before breakfast. What sort of person am I?
Breakups are very good at making every passing feeling sound as though it has been sent downstairs with an important message. Usually it has not; sometimes a feeling is simply a feeling with excellent confidence.
1.
Feeling Terrible Does Not Mean the Breakup Was Wrong
This one is deeply inconvenient because we like good decisions to come with pleasant confirmation.
You end a relationship that has been making you unhappy for months, and somewhere in the imagination there is an expectation that by Friday you will wake up glowing, make coffee near an open window and think, Yes. Splendid decision.
Instead, Friday arrives and you are crying because you found his favorite mustard in the refrigerator.
Very confusing.
The breakup may have been sensible, necessary and overdue, yet somehow you still feel as though somebody has removed an entire room from your house. Of course you do. A relationship can be wrong for you and still have been part of your everyday life.
But sadness is extremely persuasive when it catches you alone at 10:42 p.m.
Look how miserable you are, it says. Clearly we should reverse everything.
No. You are miserable because something mattered and now it is over.
Those are not the same thing.
Some correct decisions feel dreadful before they feel peaceful, which is frankly poor design, but nobody consulted us.
2.
A Beautiful Memory Is Not a Vote to Reopen the Relationship
Memory becomes absolutely shameless after a breakup.
For months it had access to the complete collection: the lovely dinners, the silly jokes, the affection, the disappointment, the recurring argument, the thing he kept doing after promising not to do it, and that one Sunday afternoon when you seriously considered moving to another continent.
Then the relationship ends and memory suddenly develops exquisite taste.
Out comes the weekend by the sea, complete with him laughing, that lovely little restaurant and the moment he reached for your hand, as though Memory has prepared a very selective highlights reel for the evening.
Yes, Memory. We remember.
Curiously, it has misplaced the three-hour argument that happened two days later.
This is how one beautiful recollection can wander into your evening looking so persuasive that, for several minutes, the entire relationship begins receiving an unauthorized renovation.
You are no longer remembering a complicated man with whom things did not work. You are remembering one particularly charming scene starring a man who appears to have had no flaws before or after lunch.
The memory is perfectly real; it has simply turned up without the rest of the relationship.
You had wonderful moments and you still broke up, and somehow both things can sit in the same room even while Memory keeps trying to shove one behind the curtains.
3.
Relief Can Sit Right Next to Heartbreak
Relief is probably the strangest breakup feeling because nobody knows quite what to do with it.
You may still be devastated, still miss him and still wish things had turned out differently, and yet Sunday afternoon arrives and something feels... easier.
Nobody is withdrawing halfway through a conversation. Nobody is making you wonder why the mood changed. Nobody has said “nothing” in a tone suggesting that nothing is about to ruin the next four hours.
You are sad, certainly.
But you are also eating toast in extraordinary peace.
This can feel almost disloyal, as though heartbreak has caught you enjoying yourself without permission.
And yet relief is not sneaking around behind love’s back. Sometimes it simply notices that a difficult room has gone quiet.
You can miss what was lovely and still enjoy the fact that nobody has spoiled breakfast.
The heart, meanwhile, seems perfectly happy to hold two opposite opinions before lunch and sees no particular reason to tidy either one away, so the next time sadness, Memory and relief all start talking at once, you do not necessarily have to decide which one is right.
Sadness may insist the breakup was a mistake.
Memory may produce romantic Vienna.
Relief may quietly point out that Sunday has become rather peaceful.
They can all be telling the truth about something.
They just do not get the final word.
✦
Continue reading
A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between
A little more support
If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.
Explore online counseling →I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.
From Alexandra’s bookshelf
Sassy Bitch Reference Guide
What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.
Explore the book →