A New Romance With Someone Else’s Fingerprints All Over It

Dating a man who is still hung up on his ex can be wonderfully confusing because, from a respectable distance, everything appears to be in order. The old relationship is over, the former woman has been returned to the past, and you are now occupying the rather attractive position beside Sir.

One might reasonably assume this means something new has begun.

And for a while, it does feel new. Then her name starts turning up rather often for someone who is no longer supposed to be part of the story.

She turns up in anecdotes, preferences, stray memories and comparisons Sir probably does not even hear himself making. You order something and discover she adored it. You dislike something and learn she did too. A perfectly innocent conversation about pasta somehow ends with Linda, as though the woman has been waiting politely in the hallway for someone to give her an entrance.

Eventually, you begin to suspect that Sir’s ex may have moved out without quite surrendering her key.

Her Name Is Still on an Awful Lot of Things

At first, you are beautifully civilized about all of this. A grown man has a past, after all, and no sensible woman expects him to emerge from a velvet box with the protective wrapping still on.

But a past is generally more charming when it has the manners to remain behind you.

Sir’s keeps strolling into the present and settling in as though it still knows where everything is kept. Places remind him of Linda. Certain foods remind him of Linda. Even perfectly ordinary preferences somehow reveal another small piece of Linda, until you know far more about this woman than you ever volunteered to learn—what she loved, what she could not stand and what she once did so spectacularly badly that Sir can still let out exactly the right little sigh.

Linda is not actually at dinner, naturally.

She simply keeps turning up where she no longer belongs.

Someone Seems to Have Forgotten the Locks

And just as things with Sir begin moving forward rather nicely, the old relationship starts making itself felt without Linda having to appear at all.

Her name passes through a conversation and the mood shifts slightly. Sir hears from her and the evening loses a little of its sparkle. An old memory catches him for a moment, and the man sitting beside you has somehow wandered into a room you were never invited to enter.

At first, it is easy to let it pass because nothing feels quite important enough to spoil the evening over, which is precisely why it can take so long to notice. You are simply enjoying a new romance while the old one occasionally reaches through an open window and rearranges the curtains.

Sir may insist he is completely over her, and perhaps he believes it. Still, people who have truly left a house usually stop glancing back to see whether the lights are on.

Remembering Linda is not the curious part. It is how easily the memory still lets itself in.

Old love has a funny way of leaving little things behind

Alexandra

Then You Discover the House Rules

Eventually, you notice that Linda left more than memories behind. A few of the old habits seem to have settled in too, and Sir has become rather alert to anything that resembles them.

If, for example, you are affectionate, Sir appreciates it partly because Linda was not. If you happen to need a little space, goodness, here we go again—Linda used to do that too.

After enough of these little echoes, it becomes harder not to notice that Sir is not always reacting only to you. Every now and then, he is also reacting to the woman who came before you.

Which is a curious way to begin something new.

Sir would like you to be entirely yourself, naturally, just preferably not in any of the places where Linda once caused trouble.

Marvelous.

And that is when the larger absurdity becomes clear: you thought the two of you were creating something entirely your own, while the old relationship has been quietly sneaking into the new one all along.

The problem was never that Sir loved someone before you. The problem is that you stepped into what looked like a fresh beginning and gradually discovered another woman’s fingerprints still around the place.

She may no longer live there, but if Sir is still measuring the rooms by her, remembering where she stood and occasionally mistaking your footsteps for hers, one begins to wonder whether anyone ever changed the locks.

Sir may very well have moved on.

He just seems to have left her a key.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →