You Liked the Shoes So Much You Started Blaming Your Feet

A woman can forgive an astonishing amount when the shoes are beautiful, even when they don’t quite fit.

They pinch a little? Fine. Perhaps they need breaking in. The heel feels strange? You have gel pads. One toe has quietly lost all sensation? Beauty has asked worse things of us.

And some relationships are exactly like that pair of shoes. You love the look of them, you desperately want them to fit, and when they begin hurting, the first thought is not always, These shoes are wrong for me.

Oh no. You start adjusting your feet.

Sir is not terribly affectionate, so perhaps you need less affection. He needs oceans of space, so suddenly you are becoming wonderfully independent. You would quite like to see him more often, but nobody wants to be that woman when Sir seems perfectly happy with less.

Look at you. Flexible already.

Meanwhile, the relationship has not changed one bit.

The shoes are still gorgeous, and they still pinch.

A Little Pinching Never Hurt Anybody

A bad fit can travel surprisingly far when you really like the shoes.

Nothing feels dreadful enough to justify flinging them across the room. Sir has his ways. You have yours. Perhaps this is simply what happens when two people are different, and perhaps the left shoe will become delightful after another six months.

So one little adjustment becomes another, and before long you have changed your entire walk around something that has not moved an inch.

Nobody begins with, These shoes hurt terribly, so naturally I shall reorganize my foot.

You simply stop taking long walks.

Relationships can wander the same way. Something you once wanted starts feeling like too much trouble to keep asking for, then another thing quietly joins it. A little less affection here, a little less time there, one more conversation you decide not to have because honestly, who has the energy to spend another evening explaining why seeing your boyfriend would be nice?

And would you look at that.

The relationship fits much better.

You, unfortunately, are walking sideways.

A relationship can survive quite a lot once a woman has decided to be understanding

Alexandra

Somehow Your Feet Became the Problem

Then comes the really marvelous part: the shoes remain exactly as they were, but somehow everybody becomes terribly interested in your feet.

Perhaps you are too sensitive. Perhaps you expect too much. Perhaps you should relax, give things time, and allow the left foot several more months to improve its attitude.

The shoe has been pinching since the first evening, but somehow the toe is now answering questions.

Liking a man can make a woman wonderfully imaginative. Your girlfriend tells you her man barely makes time for her and you know within eleven seconds that this is ridiculous. Sir barely makes time for you and suddenly we must consider his workload, childhood, personality, sleep schedule, recent stress, and whether perhaps his own calendar frightens him.

Naturally, your girlfriend is limping and must remove the shoes immediately; you, meanwhile, are merely breaking yours in.

By now there may be gel pads, blister patches, shorter walks, and one toe you have stopped discussing in polite company, while the shoes themselves remain mysteriously innocent.

They are beautiful, after all.

Then You Notice the Limp

Eventually, the whole thing gives itself away, usually in some annoyingly ordinary moment.

You hear yourself explaining the relationship and realize the explanation has become longer than the happy part. Or another woman casually says how much she enjoys affection, effort, and actually spending time with her boyfriend—and for one tiny second you remember: Oh. I used to want that too.

That is when you notice how much bending has been happening on your side.

Not all at once, and not in some grand scene. More like months of softening things, excusing things, waiting a little longer, wanting a little less, until one small moment finally makes the whole thing look different.

All to keep one beautiful thing from admitting it does not fit.

And once you finally see that, the whole situation shifts. The shoes may still be beautiful; that was never really the problem.

They just hurt.

Which is almost annoyingly simple after all those gel pads.

A relationship can have chemistry that behaves badly, lovely little moments, and just enough sparkle to keep a woman making excuses far longer than she planned. None of that means you should have to lose feeling in three toes just to stay in it.

You liked the shoes. You wanted the shoes. You may even have looked spectacular in them.

But after enough limping, even the prettiest pair runs out of excuses.

Your feet were never the problem.

The relationship simply was not the right fit.

✦

Continue reading

A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between

A Private Place to Talk

BetterHelp offers private online access to licensed therapists, wherever you feel most comfortable talking.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →