The Woman Who Won’t Leave Him Alone

Sometimes you are happily dating a man when another woman starts appearing in places she really ought to have disappeared from by now.

Not in person, necessarily. Nothing so convenient. She appears as a name on Sir’s phone, a call he needs to take, a story that begins with she contacted me again, or one of those peculiar changes in his mood that enters the evening without having been invited.

You soon learn that she is a woman from his past, although the past seems to have developed an unusual amount of access to the present. Sir explains that she simply will not leave him alone.

Poor Sir. He has moved on completely, while this unfortunate woman keeps hovering somewhere beyond the curtains, refusing to understand that her part in the story is over.

At first, this is perfectly believable.

She Has an Extraordinary Talent for Reappearing

According to Sir, she texts when she should not, calls for reasons he cannot understand and keeps finding little excuses to remain in his life. The only curious thing is how available Sir remains for a man trying so hard to escape.

He answers often enough, knows what is happening with her, and somehow she continues to know quite a bit about him too. Their supposedly closed door seems to require a surprising amount of opening and closing.

Sir calls this kindness. He does not want to hurt her feelings or make things worse, which is very noble, although regular access to the gentleman may not be the crispest way to explain that the gentleman is no longer available.

Sir appears to be discouraging contact with unusual warmth.

The Past Keeps Spoiling the Present

Then you notice how much influence this finished relationship still seems to have.

A conversation with her can change Sir’s mood, a message can distract him, and somehow the woman who supposedly means nothing anymore manages to join you for dinner without needing a chair.

Sir says she is difficult, exhausting, perhaps a little too emotional, and she very well may be. Still, one cannot help admiring the stamina of a romance that has apparently ended while continuing to produce such lively aftereffects.

Most things truly belonging to the past eventually lose their ability to ruin dessert. This one, for some reason, seems wonderfully well preserved.

Sir Occasionally Misplaces an Evening

The little disappearances are harder to notice because they look so ordinary. Plans shift, an evening becomes inconvenient, and several hours quietly vanish beneath errands, exhaustion, somebody needing help or life simply becoming complicated.

Any one of these would mean absolutely nothing. It is only after the woman from the past has resurfaced a few times, and Sir has become mysteriously harder to reach around the same time, that the pattern begins to develop a faint outline.

Perhaps the two things have nothing to do with each other... or perhaps Sir’s free time has a sentimental streak and likes wandering backward.

Some love stories become crowded very quietly

Alexandra

Then Two Presents Turn Up

The trouble with little traces is that occasionally one of them comes gift-wrapped.

Perhaps, by pure accident, you come across two identical presents tucked away in one of Sir’s drawers, both clearly intended for a woman and similar enough to make the coincidence difficult to ignore. Soon afterward, one of them becomes yours.

Lovely.

The other disappears.

Now, coincidence is a generous creature and should always be given room to work. Perhaps Sir bought two and changed his mind. Perhaps somebody else needed one. And perhaps the second box belonged to a different little romantic story.

Still, it is difficult not to imagine another woman somewhere opening an identical present and thinking her boyfriend has been terribly thoughtful.

Two matching presents do tend to raise an extra question or two.

The Woman Who Will Not Leave Begins to Look Different

Eventually, the story changes without Sir changing a word of it.

He still says she cannot let go, yet by now you have also watched him keep answering, keep disappearing, become thoroughly affected after speaking to her and keep this supposedly finished woman strangely close to the ordinary details of his life. There may even be a second little present somewhere, having declined to explain itself.

You cannot know what Sir has told her, and that is precisely the interesting part.

Perhaps she knows perfectly well that you exist and refuses to accept it. Or perhaps the famous woman from his past has not been given quite as much past as you were led to believe.

Perhaps she does not think she is pursuing somebody else’s boyfriend at all. Maybe, just maybe, she thinks somebody else is dating hers.

And goodness, once that possibility appears, every little footprint changes shape.

You began this story believing you were Sir’s girlfriend, while the other woman was simply someone from his past who refused to accept that everything was over.

But perhaps Sir does not have one girlfriend and one woman who refuses to understand.

Perhaps Sir has two girlfriends—and only one of them knows there are two.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →