The Evening in Your Head Was Going So Well
Sometimes you expect Sir to do something you have never actually told him you want.
Not because you are unreasonable. Because in your head it feels so obvious that explaining it would almost spoil the romance.

He should notice you are upset. He should remember what you mentioned three weeks ago. He should know that tonight matters a little more than usual. He should choose the thoughtful thing without being pointed toward it, because surely the whole point of a thoughtful thing is that nobody had to point.
And this is how an ordinary dinner quietly becomes an occasion in your head, complete with expectations.
Sir, unfortunately, still thinks it is just a dinner. He has no idea that tonight now comes with emotional significance, several unspoken expectations, and a small romantic test he was never told he was taking.
The poor man has not even received the invitation.
Sir Still Thinks It Is Just Dinner
At first, the expectation can be tiny.
You have changed your hairstyle slightly. Nothing major, just enough to feel rather pleased with yourself—and certainly enough, in your opinion, for Sir to notice. You have not arrived with a shaved head and a falcon. Still, it looks lovely, you know it looks lovely, and naturally he should say so too.
He does not.
Dinner gets underway, the conversation moves along, and after a while the missing compliment begins to feel strangely enormous for something that technically never happened.
Now you are a little annoyed, which creates a second expectation: Sir should notice that your mood has changed.
Ideally, he should wonder what happened, look at you properly, suddenly discover the new hairstyle, and rescue the evening with a compliment so good that the entire matter can be forgotten with dignity.
Sir finally looks at you.
At last.
Then he glances toward the corner and asks, “Did you move that lamp?”
The lamp has been there for six months.
Sir has somehow missed both the hairstyle and the emotional consequences of not noticing it, while somehow noticing a change in a lamp that has not changed at all.
Obviously, Sir is noticing beautifully. Just not anything that would help him.
And just like that, one small expectation has turned into three: notice the hairstyle, notice the mood, then somehow say exactly the right thing. Quite a lot for a man who still thinks he is simply having dinner.
The Little Expectations Get Bigger
Birthdays are especially dangerous because expectations rarely stay modest for long.
You are not asking for anything extravagant. Goodness, no. Just something personal, thoughtful, romantic, very specific to you, preferably surprising, and ideally something you have never once mentioned wanting.
Nothing unreasonable there.
And then Sir does something inconveniently sensible: he remembers the earrings you paused over while the two of you were wandering through a shopping center and buys them for your birthday.
They are beautiful. You love them.
Which really should be the end of the matter.
Except somewhere in your head, this same Sir should have done it differently.
He should have remembered some tiny thing you mentioned months ago, chosen something you never once pointed at, and appeared with a gift so perfectly you that it seemed almost unbelievable.
But all Real Sir did was remember the earrings. He had no idea he was supposed to do better.
Romance is lovely until two people remember the same conversation differently
Alexandra
Soon, ordinary evenings begin picking up expectations too.
The restaurant should somehow be the one you were secretly hoping for. The conversation should drift toward the thing you wanted to talk about. Sir should sense that tonight feels a little different without anyone having to say so, because saying so would spoil half the charm.
Real Sir, meanwhile, may choose another restaurant, tell you a completely unrelated story, and sit there looking rather pleased with his meal.
Nothing has gone wrong. The evening has simply refused to become the one you had already approved in your head.
And Then Real Sir Does Something Better
The Sir in your head already knows everything. He knows the restaurant, the mood, what the sigh means, and whether flowers would be lovely or a very bad idea.
Real Sir knows nothing.
Which is why he occasionally does something much better: he surprises you.
He picks the place you would never have chosen and you laugh all evening. He misses the lovely sentence you imagined and says something entirely his that lands better. The romantic moment you expected never shows up, but another one does.
Rather lovely, actually, when romance ignores your careful plans and comes up with something better.
Of course kindness, affection, honesty and effort can still stay on the menu. Sir is not being released into the wild. But maybe every lovely moment does not need to be arranged before he gets there.
Sometimes he misses the evening you pictured and gives you one you like more.
Quite good, really, for a man who never realized mind-reading was part of the evening.

Continue reading
A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between
A Private Place to Talk
BetterHelp offers private online access to licensed therapists, wherever you feel most comfortable talking.
Explore online counseling →I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.
From Alexandra’s bookshelf
What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.
Explore the book →