Sir Knows Your Coffee Order but Still Can’t Say “I Love You”

By the time you have been dating a man for a year, he can know an astonishing amount about you.

Sir knows your coffee order. He knows which restaurant you dislike, which friend tells the longest stories and that you will absolutely need a sweater even though you insisted you would not.

He may have met your family, heard the story about that awful vacation more than once and learned to identify at least three people from your office purely from context.

By now, Sir knows you rather well.

And yet three little words remain mysteriously unavailable.

“I love you?”

Goodness, Madam. Let us not overwhelm him.

Sir Is Saying Almost Everything Else

This is what makes the whole thing so confusing: he certainly does not behave like a man who feels nothing.

Quite the opposite.

He checks that you got home safely, brings you the thing you like without being asked and remembers something you mentioned months ago, then appears with it later. Sir is affectionate, thoughtful and wonderfully present right up until the moment three very ordinary words wander into the conversation.

Then one evening he looks at you rather tenderly and says, “You mean so much to me.”

Ah. Very close.

Another time it is, “I’m so happy I met you,” and eventually, “I really care about you.”

Madam, we are now standing directly beside the words. You can practically see them from here. And Sir?

Sir, however, appears to be in no particular hurry to say them.

Naturally, You Begin Translating

And because you are a reasonable woman, you begin doing a little translating of your own.

Maybe “I miss you” is his version of it? “Call me when you get home” certainly sounds promising too. And then he remembers that tiny thing you mentioned weeks ago, which is unexpectedly touching. “Before long, it seems all these thoughtful little moments have quietly assembled themselves into one sentence Sir still has not actually said.

Your girlfriends may help with the translation. “He obviously loves you,” they’ll say, pointing to the coffee order, the remembered details, the small acts of care. And perhaps they are right. The slight problem is that everyone seems perfectly capable of saying it except Sir.

After a while, you are not really wondering whether Sir feels something anymore. You are wondering how a man can walk all the way around a feeling, describe the view beautifully and still avoid saying its name.

Madam, “he shows it” is lovely right up until you realize you are still waiting to hear it

Alexandra

Three Words Begin Making Quite a Lot of Noise

At first, the absence is easy enough to ignore. Then the months wander by, and those three unsaid words start becoming awfully noticeable.

He tells you he cannot imagine his life without you. Lovely.

He says being with you feels different from anything he has had before. Wonderful.

He starts talking about trips next year and making plans for the two of you, and by now Sir is making splendid progress everywhere except toward the sentence itself.

“I love you,” it appears, remains tucked away somewhere with the good china, reserved for an occasion Sir has not yet decided is quite special enough. Ahh.

And this is where it all becomes rather funny. A man can spend twelve months learning your habits, becoming part of your life, leaving half his belongings at your place and knowing exactly how you take your coffee, while three tiny words continue behaving as though they require a special occasion.

Whatever Sir’s private explanation may be, by then the situation itself has become rather hard to miss.

You are no longer examining the coffee, the groceries and every thoughtful little errand for hidden subtitles.

Because after a year, Madam, the words a man keeps carefully avoiding can become rather louder than anything he does say.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →