Sir Likes It, So Naturally Madam Has Always Loved It Too

When you really like a man, finding things you have in common can feel wonderfully romantic. Same sense of humor? Lovely. Same taste in restaurants? Even better. But somewhere between “we both love Italian food” and “I have always wanted to jump out of an airplane,” Madam may wish to consider how much of this togetherness actually belongs to her.

It begins innocently enough when Sir mentions kayaking.

You do not kayak. You have never looked at a perfectly good stretch of water and thought it needed you in the middle of it with a paddle. But he looks so happy talking about it that you smile and say you would love to try it too.

And this, Madam, is where a perfectly lovely manicure starts getting into trouble.

You are not trying to fool anybody. Goodness, no. You simply like the man, and there is something rather appealing about being the woman who enjoys the things he enjoys. One little adventure seems harmless enough. Why not?

The difficulty is that Sir has several.

Madam Is Suddenly Very Outdoorsy

Your first outing teaches you that kayaking involves considerably more paddling than the photographs suggested. Still, you eventually make it back to shore, and Sir is so delighted by your willingness to try things that the whole experience begins to look slightly more romantic in retrospect.

That compliment does rather a lot of damage.

Because once Sir starts admiring your adventurous side, you become strangely reluctant to disappoint him. The gym follows. Then ice hockey. We need not examine every sore muscle, but your weekends are beginning to look very different. A woman who was perfectly happy with coffee, lunch, and perhaps wandering around somewhere pretty is now being handed weights, helmets, skates, and increasingly serious-looking equipment.

Sir, meanwhile, is having a marvelous time, and you keep saying yes because he looks so pleased when you do. But the farther this goes, the harder each new adventure becomes to refuse. After kayaking and hockey, how exactly are you supposed to tell Sir that a mountain is where Madam suddenly draws the line?

This is how one uncomfortable yes somehow becomes the beginning of several more.

Sir does not need another version of himself. He was supposed to be dating you

Alexandra

One Month Ago, Madam Preferred Brunch

By the time Sir suggests climbing, this adventurous woman he thinks he is dating has developed a life of her own. You have encouraged her for weeks, so up the mountain you go, while the woman you actually are would still quite like to know whether there will be a bathroom.

There will not.

A few hours later, the pretty little outfit you started in has disappeared under layers you would never normally choose, your hair has completely given up, and one perfectly good nail is gone. The local insects seem delighted you came, which is lovely for them.

Sir, meanwhile, is glowing. He turns around to admire the view and asks whether this is incredible, and naturally you tell him it is.

One month ago, Madam preferred brunch. She is now dangling from a cliff because Sir once called her spontaneous.

Madam started this romance with a manicure and has somehow ended up being eaten by insects at altitude.

You might think this would be enough adventure for one romance, but Sir has recently been thinking about skydiving.

Now we have a problem.

You hate heights. You have always hated heights. But after weeks of cheerfully accepting paddles, skates, sore muscles, bug bites, and one entire mountain, admitting this suddenly feels rather late. Sir thinks you adore adventure because you have spent weeks giving him every reason to think so.

And somehow, Madam says yes again.

Which is how you end up zipped into a shapeless jumpsuit so aggressively practical that, from fifty feet away, you could be anybody’s uncle, while a stranger fastens you to himself with a parachute.

At some point while being prepared to leave a perfectly functioning airplane, you may reasonably wonder how liking a man brought you here.

Sir Finally Meets the Woman Who Likes Pancakes

A few days later, Sir casually mentions another climb, and at last the woman who has been quietly missing brunch makes herself heard.

“No,” you say. “I actually hate heights.”

Sir looks genuinely confused.

“But you went skydiving.”

Fair.

So you finally tell him what happened. You liked him. He loved all these adventurous things. Every time you joined him, he looked delighted, and somehow you kept saying yes until the whole romance had wandered much farther outdoors than you ever intended.

Sir listens for a moment and then shrugs.

“Okay. Want to get brunch?”

And there it is.

Madam has spent six weeks kayaking, lifting half the gym, sliding around an ice rink, being bitten by wildlife, climbing a mountain, and voluntarily falling out of an airplane for a man who, as it turns out, would have been perfectly happy to meet her over pancakes.

✦

A little more support

If your situation feels too specific for generic internet advice, talking it through with a professional can help. BetterHelp offers online counseling with licensed therapists, so you can get support from wherever you feel most comfortable.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →