Somewhere Between the Toothbrush and Sunday Morning, This Got Confusing

Friends with benefits always sounds wonderfully simple at the beginning.

You like Sir. Sir likes you. The chemistry is excellent, nobody is making speeches about the future, and both of you feel rather pleased with yourselves for keeping the whole thing so beautifully uncomplicated.

No labels. No expectations. No one is choosing china.

Lovely.

It is a little like taking a short-term rental for the weekend. You know perfectly well you are not moving in, so who cares about the curtains? You are here for a good time, not to reorganize the kitchen and start wondering where your books might go.

But then, rather inconveniently, the place turns out to be lovely.

You settle in. You stop checking the time. Somewhere along the way, leaving begins to feel slightly less appealing than it did when you arrived.

Nothing has changed, obviously. Except now the temporary little thing is feeling suspiciously comfortable.

And goodness, casual does not always behave itself once it gets comfortable.

Casual Is Doing a Lot of Work Here

The funny thing about friends with benefits is how long the word casual can survive after the arrangement itself has become anything but.

It can be sitting there quite happily while two people are deeply woven into each other’s lives, as though nobody has noticed that the little label is now several sizes too small.

And because nobody officially changed the rules, everyone gets to keep pretending nothing has changed.

You are not a couple.

Of course not.

You merely have someone whose absence you notice, whose attention matters, and whose place in your life has become far too comfortable to feel temporary.

Well...

At some point, “casual” begins sounding less like a description and more like a tiny hat somebody has insisted on keeping on a very large head. And that is usually where the trouble starts. Because once something feels this much like a relationship, it becomes terribly easy to assume it is slowly becoming one.

Sir, meanwhile, simply thinks the original arrangement has turned out exceptionally well—and nobody is asking him to be a boyfriend.

Friends with benefits: beautifully simple, right up until it isn’t

Alexandra

Sir Sees No Reason to Change a Thing

Here is where friends with benefits can become almost impressively unfair.

The better it gets, the more likely you are to think something must be happening.

After all, this no longer feels like two people casually passing through each other’s lives. It has become warm and familiar and far too lovely to keep sitting under such a tiny little title. Surely all this ease is the beginning of something, right?

Sir, however, may be looking at the very same evidence and reaching a completely different conclusion.

From your side, casual appears to be slowly growing up.

From Sir’s side, casual has simply exceeded expectations.

Which is rather unfortunate, because while you are beginning to wonder whether the temporary stay has quietly become home, Sir may be thinking he has found the nicest short-term rental in town.

And naturally, the last thing on his mind is moving out.

Then Somebody Mentions the Future

Friends with benefits can get away with an astonishing amount as long as nobody asks one tiny, terribly inconvenient question about the future: Where is this going?

Perhaps not even the future future. No white dress, no mortgage, no Labrador called Henry. Just some innocent little suggestion that the two of you might still be doing this several months from now.

And then—bam. Sir freezes like a deer in headlights.

Not necessarily horrified. Just surprised in the particular way a man looks when he thought everyone was having such a nice time and then you asked that.

And suddenly all those wonderfully blurry edges become remarkably sharp.

You thought the fact that this had lasted meant something was quietly changing. Sir may have thought the fact that it had lasted meant everybody was perfectly happy with the original idea.

And suddenly the short-term rental joke is no longer quite so charming.

You were beginning to wonder whether it might be home.

Sir, meanwhile, was still calling it a rental.

✦

Continue reading

A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between

A Private Place to Talk

BetterHelp offers private online access to licensed therapists, wherever you feel most comfortable talking.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →