Sir Has Read the Entire Menu and Still Hasn’t Ordered

When Sir says he is “not ready to commit,” picture a man in a very nice restaurant who has been studying the menu for forty-five minutes. He likes the table, the wine is excellent, he is delighted to be there with you, and quite a lot of bread has disappeared, but choosing dinner would be moving awfully fast.

At first, this can seem rather charming. Sir is not indecisive; he is thoughtful. One must not confuse the two, especially over candlelight and good earrings.

Perhaps he has made poor choices before. Perhaps he wants to be absolutely certain this time. Perhaps he simply needs another minute.

Of course.

You have nowhere to be.

The waiter does, but never mind.

Sir Is Still Looking

The evening continues while Sir considers his options.

He likes what he sees. In fact, he likes it enough to order another glass of wine, share an appetizer, steal one of your fries, and settle very comfortably into the evening. He is affectionate, attentive, and showing no signs whatsoever of wanting to leave.

This is what makes the whole thing so deliciously confusing.

A man who did not like the restaurant would presumably get up.

Sir does not get up.

Sir settles in.

So naturally you begin to assume dinner must be coming.

The waiter returns, and Sir needs another minute. He has questions about the specials. He would like to know what comes with the salmon. He briefly considers the steak, revisits the pasta, and develops concerns about a sauce he had not noticed ten minutes earlier.

By now, you have begun translating all this hesitation into something rather flattering: he does not take important choices lightly, he has depth, and he knows what can happen when people rush into entrées.

Goodness, you can make this man sound magnificent.

Meanwhile, the menu remains open.

Somehow, Everything Except Dinner Is Easy

The funny thing is that Sir seems perfectly capable of making other decisions.

Another drink? Absolutely.

Would he like to try your appetizer? Yes, please.

Coffee afterward? Lovely idea.

Then the waiter mentions that only one chocolate tart remains, and suddenly the fog lifts. Sir would very much like the chocolate tart.

Immediately.

No soul-searching. No difficult history with pastry. No request for six more months to understand what cake means to him.

Well, look at that.

Sir can choose.

Commitment remains complicated; the chocolate tart, less so

Alexandra

People become wonderfully creative around things they truly want. A man who wants the last chocolate tart does not spend half an hour wondering whether this is really the right season for ganache. He knows exactly what he wants.

The same man can perform similar little miracles elsewhere too. An evening that was once impossible becomes free. A distance that sounded exhausting just a week ago becomes manageable. Something he genuinely wants has a funny way of finding its way into his life.

But when the wanting is less enthusiastic, goodness, the menu becomes a novel.

Now the timing is wrong, the options are complicated, he has had difficult meals before, and perhaps everyone would be happier if nobody put a label on dinner.

Meanwhile, Sir is still sitting across from you with the menu open, somehow making dinner feel just about to happen and nowhere near happening at the same time.

Sir Has Had a Lovely Evening

And perhaps this is the part women occasionally miss because Sir does not look unhappy. He is having a marvelous time. He likes you, likes being with you, and may sincerely mean every affectionate thing he says between bites of your dinner.

None of that requires him to order his own.

So the evening can stretch on beautifully while you keep assuming his enjoyment must eventually turn into a choice. Another conversation, another lovely night, another little sign that surely means Sir has finally narrowed down the menu.

Perhaps he has.

Perhaps one evening he will close it, look up, and know exactly what he wants.

But until then, step back for a second and the whole thing starts to look rather ridiculous: Sir has enjoyed the wine, sampled the appetizers, eaten your fries, secured the last chocolate tart, and spent a perfectly lovely evening with you—and yet he is still not ready to order dinner.

And goodness, for a man who cannot decide, Sir has eaten remarkably well.

✦

Continue reading

A few more thoughts on love, dating, and everything in between

A Private Place to Talk

BetterHelp offers private online access to licensed therapists, wherever you feel most comfortable talking.

Explore online counseling →

I may earn a commission if you use my BetterHelp link, at no additional cost to you.

From Alexandra’s bookshelf

Sassy Bitch Reference Guide

What to do when he... top 100 questions answered.

Explore the book →